Okay, I admit that occasionally, I’ll happen to watch an episode of ‘The Social’. For those of you who don’t know its kind of a Canadian version of ‘The View’. The show usually has a panel of four hosts who discuss current events, entertainment and issues of particular interest to women. I don’t always agree with their take or spin on things, but the banter is quite entertaining.
Today was one of those shows in which I found myself yelling at my television. The topic was the ‘so called’ rising xenophobia against Chinese people over the coronavirus. Basically, the hosts collectively agreed there was a societal mood of racism against Chinese people and to single them out specifically was indeed a racist act. At least that’s my take- away from what was discussed.
Well, as a black man born in one white industrialized country and raised in another, I’m particularly sensitive to the issue of racism as it’s been a daunting undercurrent throughout much of my life. That being said, I’m not afraid to call B.S. on accusations of racism that don’t appear to hold much water as I think it de-sensitizes us from the real and often hard to prove instances of systemic and institutional racism that our rife throughout Canadian, American and British society.
The conversation kicked off with host Lainey Lui, herself a Chinese Canadian, stating how she felt people were somehow weary of her or judging her due to the current coronavirus. Then host Melissa Grelo went on to do a somewhat ridiculous comparison between the coronavirus and the common flu. She stated how the flu kills 3500 people annually in Canada, and yet Canadians don’t seem to raise an eyebrow. Yet this new virus from China, might actually kill less than 3500 people and we’ll be going crazy. Melissa is right and wrong. Canadians should take the flu more seriously. But they certainly don’t need to take the coronavirus less seriously. If it turns out to be as deadly as SARS, the death toll for the entire country will be less than 50 (SARS killed 44 Canadians). The economic toll on the country will be devastating as it was for years after SARS. It took several years for tourists to start venturing back to Toronto. And that is the best-case scenario. What if this turns out to be a pandemic? What if hundreds and possibly thousands of people die?
And then the mood on the show turned sour as Lainey read out a Facebook post from somebody named Ruth. According to Ruth, she didn’t think the current mood was down to racism. She also suggested there should be a travel ban. The reaction from the hosts was to be expected – all of them were aghast at the comment. Melissa went on to mention how the term ‘Travel Ban’ harkens to Donald Trump’s racist travel ban. This is where I started to scratch my head. Come on now! How on earth do you compare a racist travel ban against Muslims to a travel ban to ward off a potentially deadly pandemic? Isn’t that a bit of a stretch?
Yes, I totally agree that during times of crisis we need to be careful that our fear doesn’t cause unwarranted and unjustified scapegoating of individuals or people from a certain ethnic group. Because if left unchecked, that fear can quickly escalate to persecution and xenophobic violence. But that is not what is happening in Canada. And I’m quite certain there are many Chinese Canadians who would be in favour of a travel ban if this virus gets completely out of control.
What Melissa Grelo, Cynthia Loyst, Lainey Lui and fill in host, Jess Allen fail to understand is this virus didn’t start in England, or Jamaica or Italy. It started in China. Therefore, if China and people who have recently come from China are now the focus of the world’s attention, isn’t it for good reason? What are we supposed to do, pretend the virus doesn’t originate in China? Maybe we should just pretend it’s really from the United States. Or even better yet, it came from Mexico via an illegal immigrant from Honduras, trying to circumnavigate Trump’s nonexistent border wall. It’s absurd.
And people most definitely have the right to be concerned that flights from China seem to be coming in unchecked as was apparently the situation with the first case in Canada. That person wasn’t feeling well on a plane, on his way back from Wuhan and yet somehow managed to pass through Customs. Now his wife also has the coronavirus. And today we learned British Columbia has its first case and it’s a person who recently returned from China. So, are we just supposed to ignore where he returned from? Really?
On Monday, both Germany and Japan announced cases of the coronavirus in which people who hadn’t been to China caught the virus……………from people who had recently been to China. The virus is now in over 16 countries and the numbers are increasing rapidly.
Just today United Airlines announced a significant decline in demand for flights to China and will temporarily suspend flights between the US and Beijing, Hong Kong and Shanghai. In fact, speaking of Hong Kong. Its leader Carrie Lam announced that starting on Thursday, train and ferry service between the Mainland and Hong Kong will be suspended due to the coronavirus. I’m assuming the hosts of ‘The Social’ will now accuse the people of Hong Kong of being self-hating Chinese people? Afterall, it must be down to racism they are doing this, right? By the way, Hong Kong leader Carrie Lam wore a facemask at the press conference in which she announced the suspension of ferry and train service.
I’m hoping the hosts of the view were equally up in arms when bans and restrictions were put in place during the Ebola crisis in 2014. I’m hoping they argued vociferously against Canada following Australia’s lead in instituting a visa ban for travelers from West African countries that were battling Ebola https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/ebola-canada-suspending-visas-for-residents-of-outbreak-countries-1.2820090.
Several Caribbean countries including Jamaica (where my parents are from), Trinidad and Tobago and St. Lucia took steps to ban travelers from West Africa or put restrictions on them during the Ebola crisis. Was this down to common sense or self hate?
The hosts of ‘The Social’ are certainly entitled to their opinion. Sometimes I agree with them and sometimes I don’t. Such is life. And I can’t tell Lainey not to feel how she feels. But I think in this circumstance it helps to sit back and consider the totality of the situation. Racism is indeed real. But this ain’t it!